A frustrating evening!

Tonight's judge was without doubt a competent photographer and many of his comments were very helpful. However, as an ARPS he is no doubt used to moving in higher circles than our humble little club. He spent most of the first half of the evening critiquing the quality of the mounts people had chosen or the quality of the mounting itself. It would have been so much more helpful if he'd spent as much time sharing his undoubted wisdom about the actual photos!

I was quite perturbed by many of his comments so when he came to comment on my single entry I was braced for a full onslaught! True to form, he did not like the colour of the mount I had chosen. The truth is, when I hurriedly came to select and print off a photo last night for the competition, it was the only colour of mount I had! I know that I also rushed the cutting of the aperture and parts of it are not acceptable - but he had obviously detected we were all getting a bit fed up with comments about mounts and he didn't mention it!

Instead, he waxed lyrical about the compositional qualities of my entry and ended up giving it 2nd place! Wow. It's a good feeling. Afterwards, some other club members were quick to come up and say how much they liked the colour of the mount and how they felt that anything different would have negatively impacted its presentation. There you go. What do I know?

Here's the photo:

At anchor